The Most Delish Duck Key Restaurants

Known for outstanding seafood and unique Caribbean flavors, the Florida Keys boast numerous fabulous restaurants. With so many great Keys restaurants to choose from, deciding where to dine can be a challenge. While you’re on your next vacation to Duck Key, you won’t want to miss out on these delish restaurants, organized by price.

To make planning your trip to the Florida Keys easier, we've rounded up the best restaurants in Duck Key, from seafood restaurants and steakhouses to delis and ice cream parlors.

Fine Dining in Duck Key

Ready to go all out? For an upscale dining experience, try one of Duck Key's most refined restaurants.

Sixty-One Prime

Address: Hawk Cays Resort Lobby, 61 Hawks Cay Blvd, Duck Key, FL 33050

For the most luxurious breakfast in Duck Key, check out Sixty-One Prime for delectable waffles, pancakes, and omelets. Swing by again at dinnertime for impressive Key West shrimp, scallops, and steaks. Feel free to indulge in the restaurant's extensive menus of wine and hand-crafted cocktails.

Angler & Ale

Address: Hawk Cays Resort Marina at 61 Hawks Cay Blvd, Duck Key, FL 33050

Stop by Angler & Ale in the Hawks Cay Resort Marina at lunch or dinner time. Try the local catch of the day or sample delightful menu options like fish tacos, conch chowder, or crab cakes. Angler & Ale's dockside location makes it the perfect place to look out over the bay and watch passing boats.

Key Colony Inn

Address: 700 W Ocean Dr, Key Colony Beach, FL 33051

For an Italian twist on local seafood, try the Key Colony Inn. Choose from numerous pasta dishes or seafood specialties, like Sicilian Dolphin, Mermaid's Delight, and Keys Fish Key Largo. Key Colony Inn also offers American favorites like BBQ ribs, New York strip steak, and fried chicken. Dine-in at Key Colony Inn for a refined dining experience, or get take-out to enjoy your meal to-go.

Casual Dining in Duck Key

The Duck Key area has numerous venues for more casual dining too. These moderately-priced Keys restaurants offer great breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert options.

Island Fish Company

Address: 12648 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050

Head over to Marathon and relax alongside the Florida bay at Island Fish Company. This laidback restaurant boasts the longest tiki bar in Florida, exceptional locally-inspired entrees, and a gift shop full of memorable treasures. The menu's highlights include seafood dishes like BBQ Shrimp, Fried Mahi Mahi, and the Grouper Sandwich. Enjoy breakfast, lunch, or dinner at the Island Fish Company, or come on by for happy hour daily from 3 to 5 pm.

Frank's Grill

Address: Town Square Mall at 11400 Overseas Hwy #16, Marathon, FL 33050

Also located in Marathon, Frank's Grill is a boisterous Italian restaurant open for lunch and dinner. Various pasta dishes and sandwiches comprise the bulk of Frank's lunch menu. Meanwhile, fish is the dinnertime specialty.

Fish Tales Market & Eatery

Address: 11711 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050

Fish Tales Market & Eatery claims the title of Marathon's oldest fish market and restaurant. Dine on fresh fish and seafood alongside homemade sausages, burgers, and steaks. Enjoy various German and craft beers on tap. Or check out the retail market for fresh seafood, meats, and hand-cut Certified Angus Beef.


Address: The Lagoon on Grassy Key at 59300 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050

Relax among tropical fruit trees and herb gardens at Bongos. The bar is open daily, serving over 20 craft beers on tap and various signature craft cocktails. You can enjoy sandwiches, bowls, and wraps from Wednesday through Sunday. Explore delicious Caribbean flavors with dishes like mojo pork, brown stew chicken, and the Cuban dip sandwich.

Hawks Cay Marketplace

Address: Near the Hawks Cay Resort Pool at 61 Hawks Cay Blvd, Duck Key, FL 33050.

While relaxing at the Hawks Cay Resort's massive resort pool, enjoy a full breakfast bar and coffee bar at Hawks Cay Marketplace. Want something a little more filling? The Marketplace offers pressed paninis, sandwiches, and pizzas too.

Sweet Savannah's Bake Shop & Ice Cream Cafe

Address: 8919 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050

Got a sweet tooth to satisfy? Sweet Savannah's Bake Shop & Ice Cream Cafe won't disappoint! Sample rotating cupcake flavors, 29 locally made small-batch ice cream varieties, or delicious baked goods like brownies, cookies, and cake balls. And, of course, what trip to the Florida Keys would be complete without trying a slice of Sweet Savannah's award-winning key lime pie?

Budget Bytes in Duck Key

Want to save a little money on your trip to the Florida Keys? These laidback eateries can satisfy your cravings without breaking the bank.

Marathon Bagel Co.

Address: 11090 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050

For the best authentic New York-style bagels in the Florida Keys, check out Marathon Bagel Co. Choose from over 12 bagel flavors and 12 different sweet and savory cream cheeses. Or try the daily specialty bagel for a unique treat!

Conch Key Deli

Address: 3 N Conch Ave, Duck Key, FL 33050

Tucked away in the Bay View Inn Store, Conch Key Deli is a small deli serving bold sandwiches on fresh-baked bread. Select one of the menu's signature sandwiches or build your own to taste.

Curly's Coffee Company & Marina

Address: 11601 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050

Curly's Coffee Company & Marina is the Florida Keys' only waterfront drive-thru coffee kiosk. Choose from various hot coffees and teas or iced coffees, teas, and smoothies. Lattes and smoothies come in seven different flavors. This seaside kiosk also offers kayak and paddleboard rentals. Have the watercraft delivered to your desired location, or rent them on-site.

Dining at the Best Duck Key Restaurants

Duck Key features plenty of great dining options for any budget or taste. Enjoy outstanding seafood, explosive Caribbean flavors, and unforgettable ocean views at Duck Key's best restaurants.