Cool Off with the Best Ice Cream in Marathon, FL

Nestled in the heart of the beautiful Florida Keys, Marathon is a vibrant coastal town known for its stunning beaches, crystal-clear waters, and a wide array of culinary delights, including ice cream & frozen treats.

Whether you're seeking a refreshing escape from the warm Florida sun or simply indulging in a sweet craving, Marathon Key boasts a selection of delightful ice cream parlors that will satisfy even the most discerning taste buds.

Whether you prefer traditional favorites like vanilla and chocolate or crave bold and inventive flavors, there's no shortage of options to satisfy your sweet tooth in this tropical paradise. So sit back, relax, and get ready to discover the best ice cream near your Marathon vacation home!

Paradise Flavors

Photo Credit: Blueee77

  • Price: $
  • Address: 9601 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL
  • Website: Paradise Flavors
  • What to Order: Key Lime Pie-Leta, Buffalo Mango

Step into a world where ice cream dreams come true—Paradise Flavors in Marathon is not your average ice cream parlor. With an extensive menu featuring an array of frozen treats, this charming establishment is a haven for ice cream enthusiasts and those seeking a diverse range of delightful desserts.

From classic ice cream flavors to unique creations like s'mores and buffalo mango, Paradise Flavors is a true paradise for the taste buds.

While their ice cream is undeniably the star of the show, Paradise Flavors offers much more than just scoops. Indulge in their heavenly Frozen Yogurt Bars, filled with a delightful medley of mixed berries and granola and drizzled with local wild honey—a healthy yet indulgent treat that satisfies both your sweet tooth and your desire for freshness.

If you're craving a taste of Mexico, their Paletas, Aguas Frescas, and Mangonadas will transport you to the streets of a vibrant Mexican mercado, with each bite or sip bursting with authentic flavors.

But the frozen delights don't stop there. Paradise Flavors takes pride in catering to every craving. Milkshakes, Frappuccinos, and Fresh Fruit Cups provide a refreshing alternative to traditional ice cream, while their Banana Splits and Sundaes are indulgent classics that never disappoint.

Conch Custard

Photo Credit: Conch Custard

  • Price: $
  • Address: 11524 Overseas Highway Suite #4, Marathon, FL
  • Website:
  • What to Order: Cherry Chocolate Chip, Root Beer Float, Pistachio

Located in the heart of the Florida Keys, Conch Custard is a hidden gem that embodies the spirit of homemade ice cream with a touch of whimsical charm. This delightful ice cream parlor offers a delectable range of flavors and special treats that will tickle your taste buds and ignite your sense of fun and nostalgia.

One of the standout features of Conch Custard is its commitment to creating unique and tantalizing flavors. Imagine indulging in a scoop of Confetti Cake ice cream, where every bite is a celebration with bursts of colorful sprinkles and rich cake batter.

For a taste that will transport you back to your childhood, their gluten-free Watermelon Italian Ice is a must-try. With its sweet and refreshing flavor reminiscent of the beloved Jolly Rancher candy, it's sure to make your taste buds dance with delight.

Sweet Savannah's Bake Shop & Ice Cream

Photo Credit: Sweet Savannah's Bake Shop & Ice Cream Cafe

  • Price: $
  • Address: 8919 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL
  • Website:
  • What to Order: Orange Pineapple Ice Cream, Oreo Heath Bar Crunch

When it comes to indulging in irresistible desserts with a touch of southern flair, Sweet Savannah of the Florida Keys is a destination that delights locals and visitors alike.

While Sweet Savannah is renowned for its refreshing homemade ice cream, decadent cakes, and cupcakes, their offerings extend far beyond those delights. Indulge in a wide range of baked goods, including cookies, brownies, and pies, each lovingly made with high-quality ingredients and a passion for perfection. Their signature Key Lime Pie is a must-try, capturing the tangy and refreshing flavors of the Florida Keys in every bite.

Sweet Savannah's selection of handcrafted ice cream, milkshakes, and sundaes will satisfy any craving. Treat yourself to a scoop of creamy vanilla or try one of their inventive 29 flavors like Salted Caramel Pretzel or Chocolate Peanut Butter Swirl.

Shiver Me Timbers

Photo Credit: Debbie Peters

Embark on a whimsical and swashbuckling ice cream adventure at Shiver Me Timbers, a delightful ice cream parlor nestled within Seven Mile Grill in Marathon, Florida. As you enter this maritime-themed paradise, you'll be transported to a world of pirates, treasure, and irresistible frozen delights.

From the moment you enter, you'll be greeted by a nautical-inspired décor, complete with pirate flags, ship's wheels, and seafaring memorabilia that add a dash of seafaring charm to your ice cream experience. The playful atmosphere is perfect for families and children, creating an immersive and memorable visit.

With over 15 flavors to choose from, including classics like chocolate and vanilla and inventive options like Pirate’s Plunder and Sunken Treasure, there's a scoop to please every palate.

One of the highlights at Shiver Me Timbers is their signature banana split, the Banana Pontoon. For the best banana split you’ve ever had, it’s a must-try - a treat that will make you feel like you’ve discovered a hidden treasure.

In addition to their ice cream delights, Shiver Me Timbers also offers a variety of refreshing beverages, including Mermaid milkshakes and floats, perfect for quenching your thirst on a hot day in the Florida Keys.

Cool Down With the Best Ice Cream in Marathon

Marathon, Florida, is a haven for ice cream enthusiasts, offering a diverse range of delightful parlors that cater to every taste and preference. From the tropical flavors of Paradise Flavors to the homemade delights of Conch Custard, and the southern charm of Sweet Savannah's, each ice cream parlor in Marathon has its own unique offerings and ambiance that adds to the overall experience.

Haven’t booked your vacation rental yet? Get in touch with us today at Coco Plum Vacation Rentals.